Wealthy Living Paycheck-To-Paycheck? More Pressure on Tenant Screening

When you hear the term "paycheck to paycheck" you probably think of low-income households struggling to make ends meet. That's even the title of a new HBO documentary highlighting the plight of America's working poor. But a new paper released at the Brookings Institution's BPEA conference Friday finds that a sizeable number of wealthy households are living paycheck to paycheck, too.

"The Wealthy Hand-to-Mouth," by economists at Princeton and New York University, finds that roughly one-third of American households -- 38 million of them -- are living a paycheck-to-paycheck existence. These are families who hold little to no liquid wealth from cash, savings or checking accounts. But a staggering two-thirds of these households are not actually poor; while they resemble poor families in their lack of liquid wealth, they own substantial holdings ($50,000, on average) in illiquid assets. Because this money is locked up in things like their houses, cars and retirement accounts, they can't easily dip into it when times get tough.

Christopher Ingram (Washington Post 3/21/14)

When running tenant rental applications, property managers and landlords are largely looking for one thing: tenants who will pay on-time and in-full every month (while not committing felonies in between “House Damage” parties).  We are looking at credit scores, criminal background checks, income, and landlord history.  But is this sufficient?

Based on the article above, prospective tenants that we once thought looked great on paper may be riskier than we thought.  For example, a house renting for $2K/month may draw the following applicant:

Married couple

Husband makes $96K/year

Wife stays home with 2 children

No criminal record besides 2 speeding tickets in the last 5 years

760 & 720 credit scores

Owned a home in their old town which they sold to move here for a job

They look like great candidates!  But let’s dig deeper with a back-of-the-napkin calculation when we delve into their credit report and specifically, their monthly cash inflows and outflows:

$8,000.00 Salary

less taxes (approx 40%):         ($3,200)

2 car payments:                       ($1,000)

Rent:                                       ($2,000)

Utilities                                   ($300)

Student loans                          ($200)

Private school (children)         ($600)

Credit card balances               ($100.00 minimum payment)

Car insurance                          ($250)

Food??
Activities??

Gas??

With $7,650.00+ in estimated monthly expenses, making $8K/month turns out to be tight.  If something happens unexpectedly (sickness?) or job loss (just moved here for a job), this could get bad in a hurry.  We know cash flow will be insufficient to cover the rent, so the question becomes how many assets do they have?  And how liquid are those assets?

And then the line of questioning turns into “Do we know?  Did we even ask?”

At the end of the day, the rental application can’t really devolve into a mortgage application-like colonoscopy.  It’s too painful for everyone involved and takes too much time. 

The good news is that a run-of-the-mill credit report is pretty thorough.  The credit report screening starts with looking where cash flow is going monthly and then factoring in the other common monthly expenses (car insurance, gas, utilities, cell phones, etc.).  If large credit card balances are present, it’s probably indicative that their expenses are more than their incomes.  Using a back-of-the-napkin look at their income and monthly expenses (coupled with alarm bells for any large credit card balances) will give a good idea of how risky the applicants are.  If there is sufficient cash flow left over each month, approve them and move on.  If it looks to be too close for comfort, ask more questions.  Ask for more documentation of assets.  And then reject the application or ask for a bigger security deposit.

Applications are about present qualifications, but also about future vulnerabilities.  Few things always go perfectly for everyone; this is real life we are talking about!  And if things don’t add up, it would behoove you to get to the bottom of it as opposed to just taking the path of least resistance.  High income and credit scores may not be grounds for fast track application approval anymore.  Times change and we need to change with them.

Happy tenant screening! 

Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Residential Property Management), the trusted real estate advisor for Charlotte landlords & Home of $100 Flat Fee Property Management.   BDF Realty utilizes their innovative Pod System for exceptional customer service in residential property management, home repairs, and home sales for single-family homes, condos, and town homes in the Charlotte-Metro Area.  Contact Us Today!