Tuesday, February 25, 2025

The “One Mistake” Case Against Rental Home Self-Management

 


“You don’t know what you don’t know.”

Socrates

 

It has been a life-long learning process for appreciating professionals in my adult life.  Most of the time, this teaching did not come easily to me.

 

From fixing cars and watching them break down at inopportune times.  Feeling physically poorly for months until I went to a doctor who had me better in days.  Using bug spray to get rid of termites only to see them come back with a hungry vengeance until a proper exterminator was employed. 

 

To be fair, fixing things on my own outside of my sweet spots isn’t always a losing effort.  I’m always proud of myself when I can pull off some repair successfully in my house or submit some legal paperwork without any help.  Go me!

 

Likewise, in property management, there is some definite positive reinforcement for self-managing:

 

“The last tenant I placed paid on time and left my rental home spotless!”

“No one is going to love my property like I do.”

“I do a lot of the repairs myself and save money.”

“Property managers are expensive!”

“The house is right by my house.” (writer’s note: that’s a double-edged sword…)

 

It is estimated that around 50% of all rental properties are self-managed, so it is prevalent. But despite the “tenant domination” stories told by some landlords at parties, it is not all roses.  There really are midnight calls for stopped up toilets, tenants not paying rent that need to be evicted, and disgusting houses dropped into a landlord’s lap when a tenant leaves in the middle of the night.  There is actual effort and stress in managing rental properties; to do it well requires time, sweat, and educational investment.  No one can say it isn’t doable, though.

 

The biggest driver for self-management is saving money.  I get that!  There is a certain joy when all the money generated from the rental home goes directly into the bank account without any property management fee deductions.  Months (or years) that this happily goes on is certainly a case for self-management; it probably comes to a few thousand dollars in potential savings per rental house a year. 

 

But where things sometimes go awry in this calculation is that there is the “One Mistake”; this one miscalculation erases all accrued property management savings.  Whether it is a legal one where a security deposit dispensation is not sent out in 30 days and the tenant who destroyed the house has the legal right to get it all back.  Or when needed (or, sometimes it turns out, unneeded) repairs are made and the time and monetary investment keep ballooning due to unfamiliarity.  Or a trusted vendor was employed who actually shouldn’t have been trusted.  Or a tenant court date that keeps being pushed farther out due to not sending out proper notices while, concurrently, no rent is being paid.  

 

The one-offs of learning the property management business can erase all the realized monetary savings and just leave uncompensated time that could have been better spent.  That can be frustrating! And that’s the tough case against self-management.

 

The problem with avoiding the costly “One Mistake” is that it could happen in so many different areas.  And sometimes things turn into “Two Mistakes” or more…

 

Property managers aren’t full-proof, but experience does offer some benefit for steering clear of these costly errors.

 

Happy Landlording!