Thursday, July 31, 2025

Blackjack & Making Lease Extension Offers: You Gotta Hit or Don’t Hit

 


Blackjack is a classic gambling game pitting card players versus a dealer.  The goal is to have the card players’ hands total 21 or as close to 21 as possible, while not going over 21.  As the game unfolds, if the card holders’ hands stay under 22, they will be compared to the dealer’s hand (if he stays under 22); whoever has the higher total wins the hand.  It can be both exhilarating and frustrating!

 

The main conundrum for the card players is whether to request an additional card (“hit”) to pad their point totals.  The upside is that the closer the players get to 21, the stronger their card hands become and the more likely they are to win.  The downside is that if any of the players get over 21, they automatically “bust” (lose) and their bet for that card hand is immediately forfeited.

 

At casinos, it is not uncommon to hear players loudly talking about their decisions on hitting on their card hands:

 

“I knew I shouldn’t have hit.  I would have won!  Ugh!!”

“Yes!  I got the King I needed to hit 21.  Great hit!”

“No hit for me.  Dealer is going to bust!!!”

 

Both hitting and staying put (taking no cards) can be the right strategy depending on how the cards land.  But if a wrong decision is ultimately made, there is no way players can change their minds afterwards.  Once players take a card (or don’t and “stay”), their decision is cast and they need to wait to see what happens.  There are no “do-overs”.

 

As a Charlotte property manager, this reminded me of giving lease extension offers to existing tenants. 

 

From a landlord perspective, landlords want to charge the highest rent possible and have the tenant re-sign their lease at that rate.  From the tenant perspective, the tenant wants to stay and pay the least rent possible or move to another rental unit that serves their needs better (this could mean lower price, better or different location, different size unit, etc.).  Both sides have some disparate interests that need to be rectified before a new lease extension can be signed.

 

But an initial offer to extend the lease (tendered usually by the landlord) must be made.  And the question is what price should be asked for.  There are usually no “do-overs”.  The price offered is going to be what the tenant ultimately makes a decision off of.  Whatever it is, it needs to be strong and not wishy-washy.  Wishy-washy can create problems:

 

Landlord: Good morning, Mr. Tenant!  Your lease is up at the end of next month and I wanted to see if you were looking to sign for another year.

 

Tenant: I was thinking about it.  What are the terms?

 

Landlord: Well, I was going to raise the rent $200.  How does that sound?

 

Tenant: Not that good.  I thought I was overpaying now.

 

Landlord: How about no rent increase.  Will that work?

 

Tenant: I’m not sure.  I need to talk to my wife and think about it.  We’re going in the right direction, though!

 

Landlord: How about $200 less than you are paying now.  Would that work?

 

Tenant: Now you’re talking!  That’s more in line with what I think this dump is worth.  I’ll get back to you.

 

Landlord: How about $300 less?

 

This can create a slippery slide. 

 

Much like Blackjack, landlords need to look at their situation and decide how much risk they want to take on with potentially losing the tenant they already have in place.  Then they need to make the offer (hit) and wait to see what decision the tenant makes.  Sometimes, the offer doesn’t matter because the tenant was going to vacate regardless.  But often, the price is the motivating factor on whether the tenant decides to stay.

 

Smart landlords will think hard about how much they will raise the rent (hit) or whether they will offer it at the same rate (stay).  There is no middle ground- you gotta hit or don’t hit!  They know that once that card is played, there is little chance to do it over and take it back. 

 

Happy Landlording!