Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Sorting Out Large Estates & the Appliance Repairman Dilemma

 


A friend’s father passed away late last year.  When he died, it turned out that this modest man surprisingly had quite a lot of money; his son could really not believe the financial acumen he apparently had!  He left a rudimentary will that bequeathed everything to his three children (including my friend).  With this tough news, there was an economic silver lining.

 

But the father’s estate was a mess.  There were bank accounts everywhere.  He owned real estate in several states.  Documentation was half on paper and half on-line.  Some of the self-managed rental houses had leases, others were handshake deals.  There was no estate plan; everything was going to probate court. 

 

And complicating the matter, the heirs were not of the same mind.  Some of the siblings needed the money immediately, while others could afford to wait on trying to get the best prices.  It caused a lot of family unrest, on top of the grief they all shared at his passing.  A blessing had become a curse.

 

I thought of how his father could have made this process so much easier by employing professionals.  A good financial advisor could have had all of the financial accounts organized and available at the push of a button.  An estate attorney could have had the assets placed in a trust so they could have avoided probate court.  A property manager could have just kept the houses maintained and rents coming into the estate until any selling decisions were made.  The cost would have been a fraction of his total wealth and would have largely eliminated the turmoil and sheer man hours required to piece things together.

 

On a smaller scale, this reminded me of a dilemma in Charlotte property management with broken appliances.

 

Almost every house has the four major appliances: refrigerator, stove, microwave, and dishwasher.  When bought, they work and look great.  There is fully-functional, appliance kitchen bliss which is expected by tenants and required by the lease.

 

But as the years go on, appliances start to break and stop working as designed.  The question becomes whether to try to repair a broken appliance or just replace it. 

 

Employing an appliance repairman will cost around $100 to get him in the door.  Then one of three things happen:

 

  1. It’s a simple fix and the cost stays around his appearance fee (best case scenario)
  2. It’s a more complex fix and will cost around $200-$500 all-in (most common case)
  3. It’s a more costly fix and replacing the appliance is the most appropriate option (worst case)

 

After one of these options is selected, the tenant has a working appliance and everything is back to kitchen bliss.

 

A legitimate question arises: At any point, is it prudent to go directly to appliance replacement and save the $100 appliance repairman fee?  What if the appliance is 30 years old?  What if there is another, pre-existing issue already (like a broken handle)?  No one wants to waste money.

 

As a property manager, we almost always go with sending the appliance repairman for several reasons:

 

  1. Older appliances tend to last longer than the newer manufactured ones
  2. Replacement costs of $500 -$2,000 are much larger than the possibility of a quick fix at $100
  3. If an appliance is broken due to tenant misuse, the tenant can be responsible for the cost.  There is no way to ascertain this without a repairman.
  4. The tenant has less down time without a working appliance typically
  5. Pre-existing issues are usually not functionally-related and not the reason for the call

 

Much like administering large estates, professionals are trained to understand and handle problems.  They can make trained decisions that usually wind up paying for themselves at a fraction of their upfront cost.  Smart landlords are wise to employ them!

 

Happy Landlording!