Charlotte Property Management Monthly: Should I Even Bother to Try to Sell My House in this Market?

This is a question that I was posed on a call last week. For property managers, this is a no-brainer, right? It’s like any buying question to a salesperson in any industry:




Question from prospective client:

Do I need a haircut?



Barber:

Absolutely.



Question from prospective client:

Do I need insurance coverage for (fill in the blank)?



Answer from insurance agent:

Absolutely. If your family’s (fill in the blank) is important, it would potentially be devastating to live without it.



Question from potential client:

Can my house sell in this market? It didn’t with the past 2 real estate agents I used.



Answer from real estate agent (straight faced without blinking):

Absolutely! My team has a 10-point marketing plan that can sell any house in any market*!

* With a nominal 50% price reduction



So back to the original question:

Should someone even bother to try to sell their house in this market?



My answer:

It depends.



Depends on what?



You should try to sell your home if you:



1. Are living in the house and don’t have to move

2. Have a clean tenant who is amenable to showings

3. Have a unique house (be honest!) that is desirable in any market

4. Are able to afford to price the house competitively (aka on the low end)

5. Are willing to gamble and eat the rent every month and wait for a buyer who might or might not come



My answer to not bother putting the house on the market for sale is under the following conditions:



1. There are several foreclosures and short sales active in your home’s subdivision

2. You can’t afford to or don’t want to drastically discount your home price

3. The home is vacant and #3, #4, and/or #5 above don’t apply to you

4. Neighbors’ homes that are priced around the level you want to sell yours for are sitting



The simple truth is that the buy & sell real estate market is continuing on a sharp downtrend with no end in sight, while the rental market is on a sharp uptrend. Everyone still needs a place to live, but the banks are not willing to lend to less than perfect borrowers. This leads to a surplus of rental and rent-to-own tenants, and a dearth of buyers. So the question is if it is better to go fishing at the small pond stocked with thousands of fish or the big pond with 25?



Whether it still makes sense to list your home for sale really depends on your answers to the questions above. Truthfully, for most people, the best financial option is to stay put in their home. But going straight to the rental or rent-to-sell market is best for people who are:



1. In a time crunch

2. Need to move

3. Can’t or don’t want to afford 2 mortgage payments



Often, it just doesn’t make sense to put the home on the market for sale. It’s an exercise in futility and costs a good deal of money. It’s like asking out the head cheerleader to the prom when you know you are going to wind up going with Suzy next door anyway. You might as well cut to the chase and save yourself the time, expense, and effort.



That being said, one size never fits all. Determine what criteria above fit your situation and act accordingly!



Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (“Charlotte’s Most Innovative Property Management & Investment Company”), and Rent-To-Sell Realty (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”) which specialize in rent-to-own (lease options) and rent-to-sell homes. His newest book, A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!)